Case Law and Legal Summaries
Case Law and Legal Summaries: monthly overview and analysis of selected cases, highlighting implications and recommendations for practice.
You need to be a member of RiPfA to access full Case Law Summaries, have a website account and be logged in – if you don’t have an account you can create one here.
This issue considers matters including:
- Case 1 is an appeal against a decision about legal aid which hinges on a somewhat technical question about which part of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 should be used to challenge medical treatment for a person who is subject to a Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) authorisation.
- Case 2 reports the outcome of Luke Davey’s appeal against the decision that it was lawful for his local authority to reduce his care budget.
- In Cases 3 and 4 we look at contrasting best interests decisions. In Case 3, the judge reluctantly decided to prevent a person with a history of life-threatening alcohol addiction from returning to a situation where he would revert to drinking. In Case 4 a different judge equally reluctantly decided to allow a person with a serious head injury to travel abroad for the extremely risky, unproven, experimental treatment that he hoped would ‘make him normal again’.
- In Case 5 we look at a case about the capacity to consent to sexual relations where a local authority was criticised for the length of time it took to provide this person with the learning sessions he needed to gain the relevant capacity.
- Case 6 describes where a will was challenged on the grounds that the person making it had either lacked capacity or been coerced.